Insight

Insight

Sunday, 10:40 AM
22 November 2026
More

    Ten Years On: Whose Constitution Is It?

    Featured in:
    Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

    On September 20, 2015, the streets of Kathmandu were lit with lamps and loudspeakers. Leaders hailed a “historic day,” promising that the new constitution would bring equality, justice, and dignity to every Nepali. Ten years later, Constitution Day feels more like a day of contradictions: fanfare inside Singha Durbar, mourning across the Tarai, and grief for the young lives lost just weeks ago in the Gen Z protests — lives cut short not while resisting monarchy, but while demanding the very democratic rights the constitution promised.

    From promise to protest

    Nepal’s constitution was hailed as a landmark: the first written entirely by elected representatives. It carried the hard-won victories of the People’s Movement of 2006, the Madhes uprisings of 2007 and 2008, and the sacrifices of the civil war. Federalism, secularism, and republicanism — words once whispered in fear — were boldly enshrined in law.

    But the ink was barely dry when cracks appeared. Within four months, lawmakers were forced to amend the constitution to address Madhesi demands for proportional inclusion and population-based constituencies. That early revision should have been a reminder: constitutions are not static monuments. They are living agreements. If they could be amended then, they can — and must — be amended and fully implemented.

    For a generation that has grown up under this constitution, the promises feel hollow. The Gen Z protests of 2025 made that undeniable. These were not calls for a new constitution, but for the existing one to finally be respected. Young Nepalis who were told they had guaranteed rights to education, employment, and freedom of expression took to the streets when those rights were denied — and were met with bullets instead of answers. At least 74 people were killed and more than 1,800 injured. Their blood is now written into the margins of the very document that promised to protect them.

    The constitution has already proven it can bend. What it has yet to prove is that it can deliver. Until it is fully implemented, it remains less a covenant of hope than a broken promise.

    The weight of unfulfilled rights

    On paper, Nepalis enjoy 31 fundamental rights — to education, health, employment, information, social security, and more. Yet to many, these rights remain abstract promises written in ink but not in life.

    Take Sita Kumari, a 19-year-old from Janakpur, who has spent two years trying to get her citizenship certificate. Because her father is Indian and her mother is Nepali, her application keeps stalling. Without the card, she cannot apply for a passport or sit for certain government exams. “They say I am a daughter of Nepal,” she told me, “but the state says otherwise.”

    And in Kathmandu on the first day of the protest, many of young people joined the Gen Z protests, and they witnessed dozens of their fellow protesters collapse when police fired into the crowd. “They tell us we have rights,” 20-year-old Ritika Pandey from Hetauda told me quietly, “but on that street, all I saw was how little they mean.”

    For them, the constitution feels less like a shield of protection and more like a locked cabinet: full of valuable rights, but beyond reach.

    A decade of half-measures

    Implementation of the constitution has not been fully realized. Parliament passed some laws, but regulations were delayed. Commissions for Dalits, Tharus, Madhesis, and women were formed, but with no budgets or staff. Federalism was promised, but Kathmandu clings tightly to resources and authority. Political parties, instead of becoming more accountable, let corruption spread unchecked. Integrity was sacrificed to patronage, and ordinary citizens paid the price.

    The Gen Z protests were not just about a social media ban. They were the boiling over of a decade of half-measures and evasions. Young people demanded honesty, but they were met with bullets. They wondered whether the constitution protects people or only power.

    Ten years ago, Satrudhan Patel was killed in Birgunj on the day the constitution was promulgated. Ten years later, more than 50 young people have been killed demanding that the same constitution finally live up to its words. The cycle is hauntingly familiar.

    The path forward

    If there is one lesson from these ten years, it is that survival depends not only on amending the constitution but on honoring what it already promises. The 2016 amendment showed that change is possible, but amendment alone cannot fill the gap between paper and people’s lives. What we need now is the courage to implement.

    That begins with truth: the families who lost their children in the Gen Z protests deserve an independent investigation, not silence and excuses. It means that Sita in Janakpur should not have to visit offices for years only to be told her citizenship is still “under review.” And it means ending the cynical practice of filling the National Human Rights Commission, the anti-graft agency, and other watchdog bodies with party loyalists who answer to politicians instead of the public.

    To live up to its promises, the constitution must be backed by independent courts with real resources, by federalism that gives local governments the power to act, and by political parties that confront corruption within their own walls. Only when integrity becomes the norm, not the exception, will the constitution stop feeling like an unreachable ideal and start becoming a lived reality.

    Whose constitution?

    At its heart, a constitution belongs not to parliaments or parties but to people. It belongs to the Madhesi mother who should be able to secure citizenship for her daughter without humiliation. It belongs to the Dalit farmer who should not have to bribe an official just to see his land dispute resolved. And it belongs to the young protester who should be able to march with his friends without the fear of bullets tearing through the crowd.

    Until that day comes, Constitution Day will remain a day of contradictions: garlands and speeches in Kathmandu, grief and betrayal outside it, and for too many families, the anniversary of promises written in law but broken in blood.

    Find us on

    Latest articles

    Related articles

    Dr. Manoj Kumar Sharma Recommended as Nepal’s Next Chief...

    Dr. Manoj Kumar Sharma has been recommended as Nepal’s next Chief Justice by the Constitutional Council, marking the latest development in a process that briefly triggered widespread confusion and celebration on social media.

    Nepal in a Different High: The Balen Wave and...

    Today, as Prime Minister, Balen continues to hold that same attention. He remains at the center of public feeling, not just politically, but emotionally.

    Balen-Rabi Collaboration: A Contrasting Force, A Potential Win for...

    Balen is a man of few words. He prioritizes accuracy over comfort and speaks what he believes rather than what pleases. Even when people do not agree with all his decisions, many still sense something genuinely grounded in him. He carries the aura of a straightforward, no-nonsense youth unwilling to compromise on wrongdoing.

    Strengthening Nepal’s Role in Multilateral Diplomacy: From Participation to...

    Nepal must move beyond participation and become an influential voice in multilateral diplomacy through strategic engagement, stronger capacity, and proactive global leadership.

    Balen–Rabi Alliance Formalized Through Seven-Point Agreement After Days of...

    While its longer-term political implications remain to be seen, the alliance has already generated widespread discussion and renewed public interest, marking a notable shift in Nepal’s political landscape as the country moves closer to the national polls.

    तीब्र छलफलपछि बालेन-रवि एकता, सातबुँदे सहमति सार्वजनिक

    यस सहकार्यको दीर्घकालीन प्रभाव कस्तो रहनेछ भन्ने स्पष्ट हुन बाँकी छ । तर अहिलेका लागि, उक्त घोषणा सार्वजनिक भएपछि व्यापक बहस सुरु भएको छ र राष्ट्रिय राजनीति नयाँ मोडतर्फ उन्मुख भएको आभास दिइरहेको छ।